Our Family Tree House

Interesting Family Stories & History

The Cole Brothers Civil War Journey (2): Pursuing Lee to South Mountain.

Twenty-one-year-old John Foster Cole, his eighteen-year-old brother, Charles Warren Cole, and the one thousand other new soldiers of the 35th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry Regiment boarded Washington bound trains in Boston on August 22, 1862, as Confederate General Robert E. Lee was preparing for battle at Bull Run in northern Virginia. The 35th Regiment arrived at the Capitol City two days later.

“A New Regiment of Massachusetts Volunteers Passing Faneuil Hall, Boston, on Their Way to The War”
Harper’s Weekly, August, 1862.

After the Confederate victory at the Second Battle of Bull Run at the end of August, General Lee wrote to President Jefferson Davis, “[T]he present seems to be the most propitious time” to invade the North. On September 4th, 1862, the 50,000 soldiers of the Army of Northern Virginia began its entry into Maryland, crossing the Potomac near Leesburg, Virginia.

“Southern Soldiers Crossing the Potomac into Maryland on September 4, 1862”

Lee believed that a successful invasion of the North was important for the South for several reasons, not the least of which was drawing Gen. George McClellan and his 100,000-strong Army of the Potomac away from Washington in pursuit. Lee would face McClellan at a time and place of his own choosing.

In response to the invasion and as part of the Ninth Corps, the 35th Regiment left Washington on September 6th. It marched into Maryland knowing that the “short time for preparation was spent; ready or not ready, it was time for the Thirty-Fifth to take to the field, to keep it until the end.”

The 35th had been in the Union Army for less than a month and needed more training. Its inexperience showed immediately.

The morning after leaving Washington, a straggler from the 35th woke by the side of the road and “boldly” asked Gen. Burnside, Commander of the Ninth Corps, if he “had seen the Massachusetts 35th anywhere.” The General replied directly, “Oh, yes. You’ll find them all the way from here to Washington!”

“Gen. Burnside’s Corps Crossing Monocarcy on Way to Frederick, MD.”

Less than two weeks later, the 35th was fifty miles northwest of Washington and “participating” in two battles, which forced Lee’s retreat back into Virginia.  The Battles of South Mountain and Antietam were early turning points of the Civil War and, thus, among its most important battles.

The 35th was tested three times at South Mountain and Antietam.  The green, inexperienced recruits of mid-August became the battled-tested veterans of mid-September.  The transformation occurred over four days in mid-September 1862, building quickly from a quiet Sunday morning east of Middletown, MD, to the final hours at Antietam, the deadliest one-day battle in American history.

The first test was at the Battle of South Mountain, specifically at Fox’s Gap.


Upon crossing into Maryland, Lee soon realized that to move freely east of the Potomac, he would have to eliminate the threat posed by Federal troops at Harper’s Ferry.  Lee, consequently, divided his Army and planned on its consolidation several days later.  He would then be able to resume his campaign and eventually engage McClellan.

From the History of the 21st Regiment of MA Volunteers (1882).

Lee did this, knowing that he had the protection to his east of South Mountain, a 50-mile-long chain of hills running north to south.  He also knew that McClellan was a careful commander, saying, “He is an able general but a very cautious one.” 

At this point, the 35th Massachusetts Regiment, commanded by Col. Edward Wild, was the newest of the four regiments in Ferraro’s 2nd Brigade, Sturgis’ 2nd Division, of Gen. Burnside’s 9th Corps.  Each of the three other regiments in the 2nd Brigade consisted of experienced veterans.  The men of Pennsylvania 51st, New York 51st, and Massachusetts 21st Regiments had been at the recent Battle of Bull Run.  The soldiers of these regiments were all battle-tested veterans. 

The 35th and the other regiments of the 2nd Brigade marched northwest from Washington on a route that included the towns of Brookville, Damascus, and New Market.  Crossing the Monocacy River on the afternoon of September 13th, 1862, they reached the City of Fredrick, MD, which had been occupied by Southern troops only days before.

At Frederick, the Army was welcomed by cheering Marylanders who had largely scorned the occupying southern troops.  Gen. McClellan also reviewed the marching troops. 

“Gen. McClellan and National Troops Passing Through Frederick, MD in Pursuit of the Rebel Army.”

The soldiers of the 35th were so “roused” and “greatly inspirited” by the scene that the Regiment sang “in unison” patriotic parade songs, such as “Marching Along” and its chorus:

“Marching along, we are marching along
Gird on the armor and be marching along;
McClellan’s our leader, he’s gallant and strong,
For God and our country we’re marching along.”

However, they were advised by more seasoned members of the Brigade, “Save your breath, boys; you’ll need it ahead.” There never were more prophetic words.  The men of the 35th soon came to agree with the veterans and never did sing together when marching again. They learned that it was “like tempting evil fortune.”

What the parading soldiers didn’t know was that just a few hours earlier, McClellan had received a copy of Lee’s orders to Confederate generals implementing his decision to divide the Army.

Nor did the 35th know that McClellan was about to give orders for the Army of the Potomac to move west through South Mountain’s three gaps the next day.  If the Army could quickly move on to Sharpsburg, they would cut Lee’s Army in two, and Lee would be unable to retreat into Virginia.

After passing through Fredrick that afternoon, the 35th proceeded on, “Darkness gathered, but the march was continued.”  Marching through the Catoctin Mountains, they stopped in the middle of the night near Middletown, east of South Mountain. On the other side of South Mountain, Lee had been informed of the Union troop movements and prepared to defend the three gaps.

The morning of September 14th was “a beautiful Sunday morning,” the men of the 35th had no idea of the upcoming battle.  However, around 2:00 PM, they were ordered to “fall in.” Led by Colonel Wild, this was to be the 35th’s first encounter with the enemy. 

Reno’s Ninth Corps, Sturgis’ 2nd Division, Marked, included Ferrero’s 2nd Brigade & Wild’s 35th MA Regiment.

They proceeded via the “National Road” (current MD Rt. 40), turned west on the “Old Sharpsburg Road,” and climbed one thousand feet to the mile-wide summit of Fox’s Gap. They stopped just east of “the Wood Road,” which ran from Turner’s Gap to Fox’s Gap near Daniel Wise’s farm west of the Wood Road.

However, much of the intense fighting at Fox’s Gap was over before the 35th appeared late that afternoon.  The South had sustained significant losses and was falling back.  Some southern regiments suffered losses of over 60%.

As they ascended, the 35th  encountered veteran troops who “laughed at our announcements that we, such raw troops, were going into battle.”

“Confederate Dead” nearby the location of 35th at Fox’s Gap.

The 35th was soon ordered to march further up the Old Sharpsburg Road from its position and “to feel the woods in front” to determine the location of the enemy near the Wise farm. As they pushed through tangled undergrowth on the west side of South Mountain, the regiment “passed over the thick-laying bodies of rebels.” They then proceeded into the dense woods past where the South’s lines had been and returned to the clearing at the top after they found no enemy soldiers.

However, the inexperienced 35th had been clumsy enough in attempting to maintain order in the woods that they had drawn the attention of a nearby Confederate unit. As darkness fell, this unit moved against the 35th and the rest of the 2nd Brigade.

With the 35th returning and the Brigade reorganizing in the clearing near the Wise Farm, the Confederates fired from the nearby woods. The Pennsylvania 51st Regiment, being closest to the woods, responded immediately.

The MA 35th, on the other side of the road, also returned fire.  The only difficulty with this natural response was that they were firing over the heads of the prone soldiers of the PA 51st Regiment!  The Regimental History of the PA 51st credits the NY 51st with threatening to fire on the 35th “if they did not cease firing.”

The “Glorious Charge” of Union Troops at Fox’s Gap in which “The Rebel Gen. Samuel Garland Was Killed.”

While the 35th clearly showed its lack of experience, its Regimental History does not explicitly describe the firefight at Fox’s Gap.  Instead, it simply notes, “Orders were confused, some shouting, ” Fire!  Fire!” Others, more calm, “Cease firing! … The marvel was not that our raw men blazed away but that they could be stopped and remain steady while the enemy’s fire continued.”

However, Brigadier General Ferrero, Commander of the 2nd Brigade, later commented, “[We were] unexpectedly fired upon from the woods by a large force of the enemy.  The sudden fire produced the utmost confusion in one of my new regiments. It quickly recovered, however, reforming under a severe fire.”

Others who witnessed the scene thought the 35th  should not have been thrust into battle so soon.  A Captain with the 21st Massachusetts Regiment laid the fault for this incident at the feet of the commanders and wrote in 1882: 

Comment on 35th at Fox’s Gap from the History of the 21st Regiment of MA Volunteers.

At Fox’s Gap, the 35th Regiment’s Commander, Col. Wild, was wounded in the right arm, resulting in its amputation.  In addition, an officer and five soldiers lost their lives.  The injured included two officers and approximately eighteen enlisted men. 

Col. Edward Wild Wounded at Fox’s Gap, South Mountain was promoted to Brigadier General and Returned to Duty.,

It was also at the early evening assault by the Confederates that Gen. Jesse Reno, Commander of the 2nd Brigade, was mortally wounded. Today’s conventional wisdom is that a Confederate sharpshooter shot Reno. However, this was not always the case and recent scholarship points to the possibility that Reno was shot in the chest by a soldier from the 35th MA who mistook him, in the growing darkness, for a Confederate cavalryman.

General Jesse Reno, Commander 2nd Brigade, 9th Army Corps – September 14, 1862.

After the 35th returned from the woods, the confrontation near Wise’s Farm had lasted forty to forty-five minutes before night settled in, and the fighting ceased.

While pickets were posted, occasional shots still rang from the darkness, and the men of the 35th remained on guard against further attack. The night was especially cold, but they did not make campfires for fear of giving away positions or creating targets. The troops “tried to keep warm [by] walking about … and endeavoring to catch a little sleep … until the welcome sun rose.”

The morning sun of September 15, 1862, found that the Southern troops had withdrawn entirely from the western slopes of South Mountain. What had happened there the previous day couldn’t be avoided, however. The Regimental History records simply, “Those who went over the field said that the Confederate dead lay thicker to the left in the woods, but the horrors beside us sufficed.”

Some men of the 35th made a breakfast of the “cornmeal ash cakes” taken from the backpacks of the fallen Confederates.  “Others preferred to go hungry rather than do anything that seemed like robbing the dead.” They also “selected” Confederate blankets, which had left behind after, of course, searching for lice.


The boys of the 35th  had been tested, and they had passed.  While they may have bent, they didn’t break.  The Regimental History of the 35th asserts, “The marvel was not that our raw men blazed away, but that they could be stopped and remain steady while the enemy’s fire continued.” Perhaps it indeed was “the scene of unavoidable confusion.”

We have, however, other questions that remain unanswered. We’ll never know how John and Charles Cole performed at Fox’s Gap that afternoon and early evening. Did they get lost in the woods when the Regiment was told to search for the enemy? Did they panic when they returned, thinking they were being shot at? Did they make a breakfast out of a biscuit that a dead Confederate soldier had made? Finally, did they wonder if the $200 bounty they each received for enlisting was worth it?

We do know that they had been away from the family farm for less than a month. The days were also getting shorter in Boxford and the nights colder, but they became men more quickly at Fox’s Gap than if they had stayed home.


At South Mountain, the Union forces suffered 2,325 casualties, with the South suffering 2,685 and retreating from the passes. Despite the South’s military defeat at South Mountain, Lee’s decision to defend the Gaps did provide him with more time to prepare his defenses on the western side of the Antietam River.

The 35th‘s Regimental History states, “The weather was fine [on the 15th] and favorable for the movements of the armies, but the men of our regiment, after the two nights of broken rest and fatigues of battle, were happy to lie upon the field during the morning and let the warm sun thaw out limbs stiffened by the frost of the previous night..” But soon, it would be on to Antietam.


The following are useful links to resources to the 35th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry Regiment:

History of 35th Mass

History of 51st PA Regiment

History of 21st Mass Regiment

Massachusetts in the Civil War (1889)

Leave a Reply