Since May 4th, when Burnside’s 9th Corps crossed the Shenandoah at the beginning of Grant’s campaign against Lee, the 35th Mass Regiment had been “separated for the present from the brigade and detailed to guard the division supply train.”
The following days were among the deadliest of the Civil War. While the 35th guarded supplies, Union and Confederate casualties mounted to nearly 60,000.
When orders came on May 16th to rejoin the brigade, one soldier of the 35th confided to his diary: “Felt like writing home to tell of the change but thought best to let them imagine us still on guard duty.”
After marching back to the brigade on May 17th, they received orders to prepare for a predawn assault. The Regimental History notes somberly, “There was a little moon throwing its soft light over the martial scene; the men conversed quietly, in the subdued way so marked when under orders to attack, then slept, rolled in their gray blankets, and quiet reigned over the bivouac.”
Grant had outlined the role of Burnside’s Ninth Corps in the May 18th assault: ‘I want you to hold your command in readiness to move out of their present place at half past three in the morning … to follow up the two attacking Corps and support them. … I will let you know [this] evening if the attack is to be made.’”

Before dawn on May 18th, Grant launched the assault. However, Grant soon realized the effectiveness of Lee’s defensive maneuvers and his own troops’ exhaustion in the extremely adverse conditions. Grant ended the attack before midmorning.
Just as at the Wilderness, Grant could not overwhelm Lee’s forces at Spotsylvania, and he abandoned the effort. In his Memoirs, Grant simply notes, “Lee got troops back in time to protect his old line, so the assault was called off.”
He would again move his army southeast, closer to Richmond.
The Regimental History details the 35th’s assault on the Confederate position on the morning of the 18th, “[O]ur lines advanced in good style into the woods.” However, the Confederates soon “opened upon us with spherical case-shot; the bursting missiles tearing through the shrubbery and laying low several of our men.”

Brigade Commander Ledlie reported his troops moved forward “in admirable style” but could not penetrate the tangled mass of felled trees and sharpened branches protecting the enemy trenches. They faced “terrible fire” as they fell back.
The regiment “immediately” regrouped for a second advance, which proved less costly. Since the regiment’s orders were “to feel the enemy,” after reaching within “one hundred yards [of] their intrenchments, the whole line lay down, without firing a shot.” The regiment then “calmly sustained the fire of the enemy for two or three hours, with little loss to us, as the shells and bullets of the Confederates passed over our heads.” Upon orders, the “regiment retired … to the rear, as if on drill.”
The 35th Regiment diarist noted, “[O]ur small part of the Battle of Spottsylvania ended.”
However, the 35th Regiment suffered eight casualties that day at Spotsylvania Court House: two officers and six enlisted men. Among them was Corporal John Foster Cole.
Corporal John Foster Cole of the 35th Mass Regiment was shot in the left shoulder, most likely in that first, early dawn assault on the Confederate position, east of the crossing of the Brock and Fredericksburg Roads, close to what is now known as Stevenson Ridge. His wound was severe but not fatal.
A horse-drawn ambulance wagon moved Cole from the battlefield to Fredericksburg, where thousands of wounded soldiers were being treated in the homes, churches, and other buildings converted into hospitals his regiment had visited the previous week.



While Cole had been treated and stabilized, his blood loss and complications required extended care in one of the Union’s new general hospitals. He was moved from Fredericksburg by rail to Aquia Harbor, 10 miles away, and then to Washington by steamship on the Potomac River. It appears he reached Washington within a week of his wounding and was treated there until May 30th.
The last leg of his journey was a one-day trip to Philadelphia by train, where he was admitted to McClellan U.S. Army Hospital on May 31st. McClellan was part of the network of northern hospitals required in the spring of 1864.
John F. Cole died at McClellan Hospital on June 13, 1864, nearly one month after the 35th, taken from its responsibilities of “guarding the supply train,” was called into action for the first time during Grant’s spring offensive against Lee.

Cole was initially buried at Philadelphia’s Odd Fellows Cemetery. However, his parents, Ephraim Foster and Sarah (Spofford) Cole, had his embalmed body “removed to Massachusetts” on May 18th and reinterred in Boxford’s Mt. Vernon Cemetery. There he joined his younger brother Charles Warren, who had enlisted with him almost two years previously but had died of Typhoid Fever at Newport News the previous year. Their parents would later join them there in 1879 and 1899.

With their son reinterred back home, Ephraim and Sarah Cole received John Foster’s back pay and the remaining $75 of his 1862 $200 enlistment bounty. They also received an additional $100 under Congress’s 1866 general bounty law. Sarah Cole later qualified for a monthly $12 pension under a controversial 1890 law that greatly expanded Civil War pensions. While military payment records exist for John Foster, no such records survive regarding any payments his parents might have received following the death of their son, Charles Warren,.

The deaths of John Foster and Charles Warren – one to disease, one in battle – may have affected the Cole family for generations. When they enlisted in 1861, their parents, Ephraim and Sarah, had six other children, ranging from a married 24-year-old to an infant. My 16-year-old 2nd great-grandmother, Sarah Jane, was the only daughter.
As soldiers in the 35th Massachusetts Regiment, the Cole brothers traveled far beyond their New England farming community. They marched down Pennsylvania Avenue, past the White House. They pondered the significance of the unfinished Capitol and Washington Monument. Their regiment led a Corps review by President Lincoln.
While that initial rail trip from their enlistment site in Lynnfield to Boston on August 22, 1862, was exciting, they were welcomed as heroes in Pittsburgh after a rail trip across Pennsylvania.
The Cole brothers might have known the nearby Merrimack River, which was navigable for at least fifteen miles to the Atlantic Ocean at Newburyport. However, marching across the Potomac and traveling down the Mississippi on their way to Vicksburg would have been unimaginable to Boxford farm boys.
Letters they might have written home about marching through the Cumberland Gap or about the seashore of Newport News, VA, were only credible if illustrations in Harper’s Weekly confirmed them.
Like their fellow soldiers, they experienced more of America than anyone in their family before them—some in the 35th spoke of returning to these distant and beautiful places after the war.
The 1865 Massachusetts census shows how much domestic life had moved forward for the Cole family during the war: their older brother, George, worked as a carpenter in nearby Andover and now had two children. Their four younger brothers, Arthur, Joseph, Walace and Roscoe, were growing but still young. Sarah Jane had married Melville T. Wadlin, who was a veteran himself. However, none would stay on the family farm their father still ran at age 56.
Having either John or Charles return home might have saved the family farm, inherited from their grandfather, from being sold in bankruptcy when their father died in 1879.
Yet even had they survived, perhaps the brothers, changed by war and their travels, would have sought different paths entirely. Maybe the farm’s fate was sealed regardless.
Final Note on Boxford and the Massachusetts 35th Regiment.

While the farm did not survive as a lasting memorial of the Cole brothers, a monument was erected in 1875 to honor Boxford’s 97 sons who served in the Civil War. Six of the 97 names listed on the monument served in the 35th Regiment. Each served in Company F. Listed among these are also the 27 who died in service to their country.
A Boxford history shows what might have been the original design for the monument, listing solely the men of West Boxford who died; among them prominently shown are C. W. Cole and J. F. Cole.

When the Massachusetts 35th Regiment mustered in at Camp Stanton in Lynnfield on August 19, 1862, all six soldiers from Boxford were assigned to Company F. Nearly three years later, only two—Isaac Day and William Perley—were still with the regiment when it mustered out. The others had become casualties: three lost their lives, and one was disabled.
Alongside the Cole brothers, Samuel Brown succumbed to typhoid fever, just after the Battle of Antietam, in a hospital near the battlefield. The regiment’s fourth casualty, George Dodge, was hospitalized with kidney problems shortly after the 35th returned to Ohio from its summer 1863 campaign in Mississippi. He was later transferred to the Veteran’s Reserve Corps, where he likely served in Washington, D.C.
The 35th Regiment was mustered out on June 9, 1865 in Washington after participating proudly in the two day parade of the troops down Pennsylvania Avenue and past the White House, the same route they had travelled as fresh troops almost three years previous. After returning to Boston, the 35th disbanded on June 27th at Readville, MA which today is a portion of the Hyde Park section of Boston.

Acknowlegment
Thanks to Patrick Browne of the Massachusetts Civil War Monuments Project for use of the photograph of the Boxford Civil War Memorial. Further information about the Project can be found at: Massachusetts Civil War Monuments Project.
Sources
Sources are divided into three sections: official records and reports; accounts and histories published in the years following the conflict; and modern scholarly works.
First-Hand Accounts and Official Records
History of the 35th Regiment, Mass Volunteers: 1862 – 1865.
Massachusetts in the War: 1861 – 1865.
Massachusetts in the War of 1861-1865, Vol. 2 (1895)
Record of the Massachusetts Volunteers, 1861 – 1865. (Roster of the 35th Regiment.)
Grant, U.S, Personal Memoirs of U. S. Grant, Vol. Two. 1886 New York. Charles Webster and Company. Grant Memoirs – Volume Two.
Grant, U.S. (John Y. Simon, Editor). The Papers of Ulysses S. Grant, Volume 10: January 1-May 31, 1864. (1982). Papers of U.S. Grant (Vol. 10).
United States. War Records Office, et al.. The War of the Rebellion: a Compilation of the Official Records of the Union And Confederate Armies. 1891. Washington: Government Printing Office, Official Records – Civil War. (See esp. Vol. XXXVI, Parts 1-3.)
Burnside, Gen. Ambrose E., 1864, Official Report of Spotsylvania Court House. Burnside – Operations Report (Ninth Army Corps)
Ledlie, Gen. James H., 1864. Official Report of Spotsylvania Court House. Ledlie – Operations Report (1st Brigade, 1st Division).
Tisdale, Henry W. (35th Regiment). Civil War Diary of Sgt. Henry W. Tisdale, Civil War Diary of Sgt. Henry W. Tisdale
Woodbury, Augustus. Major General Ambrose E. Burnside and the Ninth Army Corps. Sidney Rider & Brother, Providence, 1867. Major Gen. Ambrose Burnside & the Ninth Army Corps.
Post War Books and Documents (1865-1900)
Cutshaw, Col. W.E. (1905) The Battle Near Spotsylvania Courthouse, An Address: R.E. Lee Camp No. 1. CV (Richmond). Cutshaw Address before Confederate Veterans.
Humphreys, Andrew. The Virginia Campaign of ‘64 and ‘65 – The Army of the Potomac and The Army of the James. Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York, 1883. Humphreys – Virginia Campaign ’64 & ”65.
National Park Service. Spotsylvania Troop Movements. (24 NPS Spotsylvania Troop Movement Maps).
Park, Edward G. (1865) A Memorial for Major Edward Granville Park (35th Massachusetts Volunteers. Boston. Memorial to Major Granville Park (35th MA Regiment)
Perley, Sidney. (1880) The History of Boxford, Essex County, Massachusetts. History of Boxford – Perley
Woodbury, Augustus. (1867) Major General Ambrose E. Burnside and the Ninth Army Corps. Sidney Rider & Brother, Providence, Major Gen. Ambrose Burnside & the Ninth Army Corps.
Modern Works (1900-present)
U.S. Army Staff Ride Handbook for Overland Campaign. (2009). Overland Campaign – Staff Ride.
Matter, William T. If It Takes All Summer: The Battle of Spotsylvania Court House. 1988, University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill.
Rhea, Gordon C. The Battle of the Wilderness, May 5-6, 1864.1994, Louisiana State University Press, Baton Rouge.
Wipperman, Darin. Burnside’s Boys: The Union’s Ninth Corps iin the Civil War in the East. 2023, Stackpole Books, Essex, CT.
