Not having found a single Catholic on the Brain side of our family, it doesn’t take a genealogist to conclude that the answer to the question, “How did we end up being Catholics?” must come from the McGurn side.
While that’s a straight forward answer, the story is both more complicated and interesting. It resulted from decisions that certain people made at different times in the past. Those decisions have ramifications that reverberate to this day.
We’ll reprint as a guide a couple generations of “Our Family Tree” for easy reference.

William Milton and Ellen Coleman
Having explored the Brain side of this tree, we turn now to the McGurn side of the family. Helen McGurn’s maternal grandparents, William Milton, and Ellen Coleman, and each of their children were baptized in the Church of England before emigrating to find work in the mills of Lawrence. Their Ashburton born children were all baptized in that town at St. Andrews Church. (In addition, Helen’s great grandparents, Henry Coleman and Harriett Gidley are buried there.)

St Andrews Church and Graveyard

Jessie Milton’s 1889 Baptism Record (first entry)
Having emigated from England, they continued to attend Protestant churches of various denominations in Lawrence and Methuen.
When William Milton died in 1924, his funeral was conducted at his home on Gage St. in Methuen. The pastor of Methuen’s Methodist Episcopal Church located in Railroad Square officated.
The 1948 funeral for Ellen Coleman was held at St. George’s Primitive Methodist Church on Carleton St. in Methuen. The church and its large pipe organ were donated by the E. F. Searles, a wealthy Methuen native, around 1910.


William and Ellen Milton, Helen’s maternal grandparents, were buried at Walnut Grove Cemetery, the town’s private but principally Protestant cemetery. Both sets of John Brain’s grandparents are also buried there.
James McGurn and Katie Gilrane
The only Catholic heritage in the family derives from Helen’s paternal Irish grandparents, James McGurn, and Katherine Gilrane, who emigrated separately from Ireland. They met in Lawrence, marrying in October 21, 1883 at the Immaculate Conception Catholic Church in Lawrence.


James and Kate’s only son, John, was baptized on August 18, 1887 at St. Mary’s Church which had subsumed the older but smaller Immaculate Conception as the main parish church for Irish immigrants. His god parents were his aunt and uncle, Stephen and Margaret Gilrain.

August 18, 1887 Baptism record for “Jno Patr.” is in the middle of the page.
When James died of tuberculosis at the age of forty-four in 1909, his funeral was held at “The Immaculate.” Katie passed away in 1937 and was also buried from The Immaculate. They are buried together at St Mary’s-Immaculate Conception Cemeteries.

James and Kate McGurn’s recent marker was placed there by their great grandchildren. The original had been lost to time.
The McGurns lived in the largely Irish Catholic section of Lawrence known as “The Plains”. It is likely their work in textiles mills gave them their only exposure to persons who were neither Irish nor Catholic.
Young John McGurn and William Milton, Jessie’s father, both worked as a “slashers” at the Pacific Mills. William’s daughter, Jessie, also worked at the Pacific in a nearby department as a “spooler’.

We don’t know the details of John and Jessie’s courtship. However, days before the wedding Jessie was baptized and became a member of the Catholic Church. Absent that conversion their marriage would have been a “mixed” marriage in the eyes of the Catholic Church and could have taken place only if Jessie pledged not to interfere with any of her children being raised Catholic.


John McGurn and Jessie Milton’s 1909 marriage certificate from St. Mary’s reveals details of their family as well as their religious history. Their “Testes” or witnesses were Samuel Milton and Emily Robinson, Jessie’s brother and coworker.
Jessie’s conversion was certainly influenced by Jessie’s Maid of Honor, Emily Robinson, and her sister, Margaret. Emily worked in the same department as Jessie at the Pacific Mills. Both Robinson sisters became Catholic nuns in their twenties after working in the mills in their teens. Jessie and the Robinsons remained lifelong friends.
Jessie became a devout Catholic and each of her six children were baptized in the Church, three at St. Mary’s and three at St. Monica’s after having moved to Methuen. Here is Helen’s St. Mary’s baptism certificate. Her godparents were her Aunt Mary McGurn Incropera and Uncle Frank Incropera.

While the McGurns moved to Methuen and became part of St. Monica’s parish, each of the McGurn children were educated at Catholic schools associated with St. Mary’s Church in Lawrence. St. Monica’s did not have a grammar school until the late 1950’s. The McGurns walked well over a mile from their Methuen home to attend St Mary’s parish schools, St Rita’s and St Mary’s.

At the end of World War Two, John and Helen returned to Methuen from Hartford and began to raise their family across the street from the McGurns. This next generation continued the tradition of attending St. Rita’s (now expanded) school in Lawrence. Only the youngest in the family did not attend St. Rita’s school. Betsy attended the newly built St. Monica’s grammar school in Methuen. Gerry and Betsy also attended St. Mary’s high school for girls.
John, however, did more than keep his promise to raise his children as Catholics. On October 1, 1951, he was baptized as a Catholic at St. Monica’s Church. Note that his sponsors were John and Jessie McGurn, his in-laws and neighbors.


After funeral masses for John and Jessie at St Monica’s, they were buried in the family plot at St Mary-Immaculate Conception Cemetery. This plot also contains family members who had predeceased them: a son, John William, who was killed in Sicily during World War II, a daughter-in-law, Mary Paquette, who died in childbirth in 1950 and a grandson, Edward, who had drown at the age of four in 1952.
John and Helen Brain are buried in Methuen’s Elmwood Cemetery with his parents, Lenny and Cleora. Elmwood is owned by the City of Methuen. Funeral masses were held for Helen and John at Mary Queen of Peace Church in Salem, NH and St. Monica, respectively.

In spite of an overwhelming Protestant background, all five children of John and Helen Brain were baptized as Catholics, went to Catholic schools, and themselves married Catholics.
How did this happen? Jessie’s conversion to Catholicism which resulted in she and Jack raising a Catholic family and their son-in-law’s, subsequent conversion is a chain of events which cannot be dismissed as mere coincidences.
I suspect that no one ever fully appreciated the role played in Jessie’s conversion by her friends, the Robinsons. In addition to being Jessie’s Maid of Honor at her wedding, Emily was godmother to Jess and Jack’s first child. Also, Gilbert Robinson was godfather to their second son. Jessie remained in touch with Emily and Margaret after they became nuns, visiting them in South Lawrence when they came home, often with the Brain children grudingly in tow.
While the Robinson parents were both born in England, the mother was of Irish heritage. The family was devoutly Catholic. The Robinsons showed by their English-Irish “mixed marriage” that Catholicism was a possibility for a person of English decent.
Did the Robinsons influence Jessie who was about to marry “a good Irish, Catholic boy” to become a Catholic? What if Jessie had not converted? Would she and Jack have followed through on her commitment to raise their children as Catholics?
Also, how did Helen and Chip’s decision to return to Methuen at the end of World War II and live near the McGurns affect this chain of events? It is clear that Helen wanted to leave Hartford and “go home” after the war, especially in light of her brother John having been killed in action. Subsequently, Chip became close to his in-laws, perhaps especially after the death of his own father. Taking some of the older children to Mass on Sunday morning while Helen stayed home with the younger ones may have been its own religious experience? Maybe he even went to Mass with his in-laws?
While we don’t know exactly how all of this happened, we do know that in spite of a very strong Protestant background, it’s difficult to reflect on our youth without thinking about either St. Mary’s or St. Monica’s Church.
The story of the Union Street Brains is ultimately a Catholic story.

Next Month: “Nana” Milton’s Backstones: The Recipe and The Story.
A Note and Attributions
Note: Emily Robinson became a Sister of Notre Dame de Namur, the religious order of nuns who taught at St Mary’s parish schools. She entered the convent in 1916 and took her final vows in 1925. Her religious name was Sister Mary Gilberta. She taught in a number of schools in and around Boston. Census records show that she attended college for two years. Her final assignment seems to have been the Principal of St. Mark’s School in Dorchester. There were approximately twenty nuns at St. Mark’s. Sr. Mary Gilberta died on September 10, 1953 and is buried at St. Joseph’s Cemetery in West Roxbury, MA. (The Provincial Archivist for the East West Province of the Sisters of Notre Dame de Namur was very helpful in providing information regarding Emily, or Sr. Mary, as Jessie would have insisted she be called.)
Less detailed information has been found regarding Margaret Robinson who became a Sister of Charity and lived in Belville, NJ just north of Newark for many years of her life.
Picture of St. Andrews in Ashburton: John Salmon, CC BY-SA 2.0. St. Andrew’s Church – Ashburton
Records from Immaculate Conception and St. Mary’s: Massachusetts: Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston Records, 1789-1920 Online database. AmericanAncestors.org. New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2019 (From records supplied by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston).

3 responses to “How Did We End Up Being Catholics?”
Keep it up brother dear. I am loving each edition
most amazing to me is our long history with St. Mary’s I have always had a special place in my heart for that beautiful church
Thanks, Gerry. We actually brought Mike back to be baptized there, making five generations of connections with that Church. It was in disrepair when we were married. Otherwise, Maureen and I would have been married there.
This was good!